SEMINAR

Inter-Generational Societal Transformation and Pakistan’s Resilience

August 22, 2024

The complete PSR is available upon request. Please use the button below to submit your request.

president

Air Marshal Asim Suleiman (Retd)

SEMINAR COORDINATOR

Dr Bilal Ghazanfar

EDITOR

Jawad Zulfiqar

RAPPORTEURS

Azhar Zeeshan, Faiza Abid & Meher Azfar Rana

Executive Summary

A seminar titled “Inter-Generational Societal Transformations And Pakistan’s Resilience” was organised by the Centre for Aerospace and Security Studies (CASS), Lahore on 22 August 2024. The discussion commenced with the keynote address by Mian Imran Masood, Former Provincial Education Minister. It was followed by insightful presentations by two experts, Mr Oves Anwar, an eminent legal expert, and Dr Yaqoob Khan Bangash, a distinguished academic. An extensive interactive session, followed by concluding remarks by Air Marshal Asim Suleiman (Retd), President CASS, Lahore, rounded up the seminar.

 

Dr Bilal Ghazanfar opened the seminar by stressing the significance of understanding intergenerational relationships for national development. He highlighted that in Pakistan, where over 65 percent of the population is under 30, the challenge lies in bridging generational divides shaped by varied experiences and values. He added that Pakistan’s youthful demographic, with a median age of 20.4 years, offers diverse perspectives and skills, but technology has heightened these generational divides by impacting communication and perceptions. To foster national cohesion and growth, it is crucial to manage technology inclusively, understand generational needs, and promote meaningful dialogue. Dr Ghazanfar emphasised that addressing these dynamics thoughtfully is key to building a more resilient and prosperous future for Pakistan.

 

Mian Imran Masood, in his keynote address, highlighted the importance of intergenerational dialogue for national progress. He discussed various socio-political and economic divides in Pakistan, including the contentious 18th Amendment, provincial biases, religious sectarianism, and socioeconomic disparities, which impact national unity and development. Mr Masood emphasised the generational divide, noting the shift from “digital immigrants” to “digital natives,” and the need to bridge this gap by integrating the wisdom of older generations with the innovation of the younger. He criticised outdated policies restricting online and distance learning, advocating for reforms to better align with global trends and empower Pakistan’s youth. Concluding, he envisioned transforming the generational divide into a bridge for progress, asserting that uniting generations is crucial for a more resilient and cohesive future for Pakistan.

 

The second speaker of the day, Mr Oves Anwar, explained that Gen Z’s comfort with technology and challenge to traditional norms are driving significant changes across various sectors. Mr Anwar emphasised the need to respect and integrate Gen Z’s innovative approaches with the experience of older generations. He criticised outdated policies and restrictive state interventions that hinder digital growth and noted Gen Z’s proactive role in recent movements, such as those in Bangladesh. Mr Anwar stressed the importance of adapting governance to the digital age and meeting Gen Z’s demand for transparency and authenticity.

 

The third speaker of the day, Dr Yaqoob Khan Bangash, delved into the critical intersection of generational experiences and the resilience of the next generation. Dr Bangash described resilience as a double-edged sword, asserting that while it is valuable, it should not be the ultimate goal. He observed that Generation Z’s rapid technological engagement reflects a constant craving for change, often without strategic direction. He cited Bangladesh’s recent political shifts as a cautionary tale for Pakistan, noting the need to address the generational divide and the rise of global interconnectivity, which challenges traditional nation-state structures. Additionally, Bangash highlighted the erosion of meaningful community engagement due to digital over-reliance and stressed the necessity for honest intergenerational dialogue. He argued that acknowledging historical truths and addressing past mistakes is crucial for bridging gaps between generations and fostering a cohesive sense of citizenship and patriotism.

 

The interactive session explored ways to bridge generational gaps and enhance youth involvement in Pakistan’s policymaking and societal development. Dr Yaqoob Khan Bangash advocated for a Pakistan-specific generational framework, critiquing Western classifications and stressing the need for a local context. Mr Masood highlighted the importance of integrating youth through effective policies and education, addressing emotional instability exacerbated by social media, and emphasising the role of the family in character development. Both speakers recognised the challenges of Pakistan’s digital infrastructure but remained optimistic about the adaptability of younger generations in digital careers. They also called for intergenerational collaboration to strengthen economic resilience and stressed aligning educational curricula with market needs to leverage Gen Z’s skills for economic growth.

 

In his concluding remarks, Air Marshal Asim Suleiman (Retd) said that as these generational differences collide, a growing number of people in our society feel marginalised, disengaged, and alienated from the broader national discussion. This growing disconnect threatens Pakistan’s capacity to tackle crucial issues like national development, political stability, and social advancement. If left unchecked, this divide could undermine our ability to build a unified, resilient society capable of meeting the challenges of the 21st century. He said that the key to our future resilience lies in fostering inter-generational dialogue, understanding, and collaboration. He added that by uniting the strengths of both the older and younger generations, we can create solutions that honour our past while meeting the demands of the future.

Key Takeaways

  • Managing the Generational Divide

The generational divide in Pakistan presents a critical societal challenge with the potential for both conflict and positive change. Neglecting younger generations’ concerns and aspirations would be a missed opportunity in shaping the country’s future.

 

  • Cultural Dilemmas

In an era of hyper-globalisation, Pakistani Gen Z faces a paradoxical situation, having to navigate traditional values with modern, global ones. Historical openness and diversity in Pakistan have declined, with contemporary society exhibiting increased conservatism and less acceptance of diverse viewpoints.

 

  • Lessons from Bangladesh

The First Gen Z revolution in Bangladesh ended without substantive change, highlighting that a desire for change without a strategic vision is meaningless, as the new government has adopted the same old tactics.

 

  • Negative Impacts of Digitalisation

Incidents like the Jaranwala church arsons, involving mostly Gen Z, highlight the dangerous mix of misinformation and digital connectivity that fuels impulsive, destructive actions. While the digital world expands interaction, it has also reduced meaningful engagement, eroding the sense of community and neighbourhood connection among younger generations.

 

  • Gen Z’s Economic Priorities

The digital realm is akin to a natural habitat for Gen Z, who are more risk-acceptant and seek alternative economic opportunities, such as the gig economy and freelancing. They perceive reskilling and upskilling as integral to their economic survival.

 

  • Citizenship, Patriotism and Brain Drain

Older generations in Pakistan have a strong sense of citizenship and pride, while the younger generation feels less connected to the country’s history and development. Political instability, economic hardship, and violence have disillusioned Gen-Z, who reject resilience as a solution to systemic issues. This also fuels the brain drain from Pakistan.

 

  • Valuing Truth in History

The truth must be valued if progress is to be made. Pakistan’s version of history is often heavily edited, with up to 70-80% of the narrative distorted in some cases. Failing to address the truth can alienate younger people.

 

  • Next-Gen Resilence

Resilence is valuable when it supports a greater goal, but it should not be viewed as the ultimate objective. It is beneficial as part of the journey, not as the final destination.

Policy Considerations

  • Inter-Generational Dialogue and Community Bond

To restore Pakistan’s social cohesion, it is essential to revive the sense of community. Investing in community building can help counter social fragmentation. Additionally, fostering inter-generational dialogue through mentorship, collaborative projects, and inclusive policy-making will bridge the gap between older and younger generations, strengthening societal bonds.

 

  • Prioritise Character Development in Education

Ensure that educational systems emphasise character development alongside skill development. Parents should model honest behaviour and in-still the right values in their children, aiming to nurture them into well-rounded individuals rather than solely preparing them for careers.

 

  • Visual Communication for Understanding

To enhance intergenerational understanding and engagement, we must translate text into visual formats. Unlike older generations, who are more text-oriented, the younger generation primarily processes information visually.

 

  • Leveraging Digital Literacy and Gen Z’s Potential

To combat misinformation, the state should promote accurate information and improve digital literacy across generations. Recognising Gen Z’s digital skills is key to addressing future challenges like cybersecurity, where their expertise can be invaluable.

 

  • Hands-Off Digital Regulation

Governments need to adopt a hands-off approach to the digital realm. State regulations could disrupt or even dismantle delicate ecosystems or equilibria that are difficult to establish.

 

  • Balancing Generational Dynamics

For a progressive society characterised by greater openness and acceptability, a balanced approach towards generations is needed. The older generation must adapt to the changes introduced by the younger generation, while the younger generation should respect their predecessors.

 

  • Localising Intergenerational Frameworks

There is a need to revise the frameworks that explain intergenerational perspectives in the context of Pakistan. Such efforts align with broader decolonial objectives, aiming to establish terminologies relevant to local contexts rather than relying on those suited to Western experiences.

CASS LAhore

The Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS) was established in July 2021 to inform policymakers and the public about issues related to aerospace and security from an independent, non-partisan and future-centric analytical lens.

CASS Newsletter

Sign up to receive occasional research insights and event updates from CASS Lahore. We respect your privacy.

@2025 – All Right Reserved with CASS Lahore.