Seminar

Emerging Trends in Aerospace Power: Options for Pakistan

August 17, 2023
The seminar examined the growing strategic importance of aerospace power, the militarisation of space, and global trends, stressing the need for Pakistan to develop a clear space policy, strengthen its capabilities, and align its aerospace strategy with emerging threats and technologies.

About The Event

The term “Aerospace” encompasses both the Earth’s atmosphere and the expanse of outer space. In the realm of strategic considerations, the formulation of airpower has matured over time, yielding a wide array of applications. However, the concept of space power is passing through an evolutionary phase. Nevertheless, space power has the ability to bestow even greater flexibility and strategic reach to military operations than its aerial counterpart. As the boundaries between terrestrial and celestial domains continue to blur, space has emerged as an increasingly pivotal arena for projecting national power, spanning civil and military spheres alike.

 

The conjunction of air and space constitutes two distinct yet interrelated mediums, each possessing unique physical attributes. Notably, both realms uphold the fundamental tenets of airpower encompassing traits such as speed, range, elevation, and the capacity to engender combative effects in support of terrestrial forces. This extends to functions like enhancing mobility, gathering intelligence, waging cyber warfare, and more. Strategists are vigorously pursuing advancements in hypersonic and trans-atmospheric vehicles, with the aim of harnessing their potential in the broader aerospace landscape.

 

Though placement of Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD) in space is banned under the Outer Space Treaty (OST) of 1967, it specifically leaves room for states to assert their dominance in space by placing all other types of weapon systems. The imminent militarisation of space shall be accompanied by establishment of intricate and multifaceted ecosystems. Several ‘Earth to Space’ and ‘Space to Space’ anti-satellite weapon systems already exist. The Strategic Defence Initiative, designed to counteract hostile Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles (ICBMs) after they have been launched, represents another array of Space to Space weapons. Former Soviet Union’s deployment of the ‘Fractional Orbital Bombardment System,’ which enabled the placement of nuclear warheads in Low Earth Orbit (LEO), shows the rapid progression of space militarisation in ‘Space to Earth’ domain. Evidently, the utilisation of space for combative pursuits is an enduring feature of contemporary strategic dynamics.

 

Aerospace strategists are endeavouring to seamlessly integrate air and space capabilities. Leading air forces are actively pursuing policies and technological advancements to secure their positions in the domain of space operations as well. While diverse approaches are evident, ranging from the establishment of autonomous space forces to the adoption of integrated aerospace force models, the overarching goal is to harness the potential of these interconnected domains. Notably, India has centralised its space assets under the purview of the Indian Defence Space Agency (DSA), a tri-service entity.

 

Pakistan’s foray into the space domain remains in its nascent stages, characterised by a substantial lag when juxtaposed with its principal adversary. This discrepancy underscores the necessity of revisiting Pakistan’s space policy, redefining the national space vision, and recalibrating the space strategy. A cogent imperative emerges to articulate clear objectives aimed at cultivating and capacitating a proficient force entrusted with safeguarding national security interests in the space domain. It is, therefore, vital to establish clear milestones for developing a viable response against likely national security threats emanating from space. Pakistan Air Force (PAF) is entrusted with the responsibility of defending the airspace of Pakistan. Due to proximal affinity of airspace and space mediums’ continuum, the PAF appears as most probable entity to take charge of space warfare as well.

 

Keeping these considerations in perspective, the seminar titled, “Emerging Trends in Aerospace Power: Options for Pakistan” delved deeply into the complexities of this realm. The overarching objective was to gain strategic insights through interaction with experts in the field, and to chart a set of actionable strategies as well as a tangible roadmap for Pakistan’s space programme.

Key Takeaways

  • Gaps in the International Space Laws

There are gaps in international space law necessitating a major review of all existing treaties and integrating them into a comprehensive international legal framework for effective governance of outer space.

 

  • Space Dominance in Modern Warfare

The concept of achieving and maintaining space dominance is vital in contemporary warfare. Lack of this capability can be sternly disadvantageous.

 

  • India in the Lead

India has a clear edge in the space domain viz-a-viz Pakistan; enablers for India’s lead are: self-reliance, consistent leadership, strategic partnerships, public private partnerships, diplomatic efforts, and a focus on R&D cantered on self-reliance.

 

  • Challenges to Pakistan’s Space Programme

Pakistan’s space programme has modest capacity and capability; lag is attributable to: overemphasised military façade of space programme, organisational bottlenecks, economic constraints, international sanctions, and absence of public-private partnerships

Policy Considerations

  • Long-Term Space Policy

Create a comprehensive National Space Policy, involving all stakeholders, focused on public-private partnerships, and resource the programme appropriately. Foster enduring international conglomerates to reap the benefits of the upcoming $1.0 trillion space economy.

 

  • National Legislation in Line With International Standards

Firstly, make provision in the legislative procedures for enacting national space law by adding “Space” to the federal legislative list, and secondly, develop National Space Legislation in harmony with International Space Law.

 

  • Self-Reliance

Establish R&D focused strategic framework that encourages the domestic production of dual-usage space technologies to seamlessly integrate commercial and military applications. Evolve international cooperation for space explorations with like-minded allied countries to bolster capabilities and knowledge sharing.

 

  • Encourage Space Education and Awareness

Create public awareness by educating citizenry about the significance of space exploration and its potential benefits by, including appropriate curriculum at the university, collage, and school levels.

 

  • Establish Satellites Constellations and Observation Sensors

Indigenously develop and launch 2-3 communication satellites in GEO, and 7-8 remote sensing satellites in LEO. Additionally, develop 2-3 sensors for specialised earth observation satellites to enhance the quality and specificity of collected data. Establish a constellation of satellites for a positioning and Navigation System.

 

  • Develop Counter Space Capabilities

Invest in the research, development, and deployment of counter-space techniques by converting existing IRBMs into kinetic CSOs.

Post Event Report

A comprehensive report capturing expert analyses, strategic insights, key recommendations, media coverage, and event highlights.

Guest Speakers

Major General Ahmed Bilal (Retd)

Former Chairman, SUPARCO

Major General Ahmed Bilal (Retd) is the former Chairman SUPARCO. He holds an engineering degree in tele-communication, besides a bachelors and a master’s degree in strategic studies. He did pioneer work in developing the structure of Nuclear Command and Control and raising Strategic Plans Division (SDP). He subsequently held many positions in SPD. He remained associated with National Nuclear and Missile Programme of Pakistan for almost 12 years. He was the first Director of Strategic Weapons Development Directorate, and Commander Signals Army Strategic Force Command. He also organised and established the Nuclear Security Force Headquarters and was its first DG Security & Intelligence. As Chairman SUPARCO he mobilised all the National Resources to boost the National Space Programme. He also spearheaded the space technology application programme to support agriculture, disaster management, urban planning, and other similar sectors. He also spearheaded the drive to develop the National Spatial Database Infrastructure, the need of which has now been acknowledged as a very important tool for better management and governance. In recognition of his services to the nation he was awarded Hilal-e- Imtiaz and Hilal-e-Imtiaz (Military).

Dr Ali Sarosh

Associate Professor, Air University Islamabad

Dr Sarosh has been a principal investigator of more than 15 high-end industrial research works funded by NESCOM, SUPRACO, and PAF. He is the inventor of two design patents in hypersonic launch systems and rocket-based combined cycle engines. Dr Sarosh has been appointed as member of technical advisory committee on global hypersonic space technologies, by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA.) He has been the founding director of the space education and research programme jointly funded by the PAF and the National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST). He is a tech entrepreneur and founding CEO of Shocks & Stars Pvt Ltd. He is recipient of the Imtiazi Sanad by the Government of Pakistan.

Dr Ahmed Saeed Minhas

Pro Vice Chancellor, DHA Suffa University, Karachi

Dr Ahmed Saeed Minhas is the Pro Vice Chancellor at DHA Suffa University, Karachi. He holds a PhD in Emerging Nexus between Space Weaponisation & Missile Shield. He also holds a master’s degree in defence and strategic studies. During his 36 years’ service in Pakistan Army, he served at several sensitive positions, including serving as UN Military Observer in Congo. He was also the Director Research at NDU as well as Director Arms Control and Disarmament Affairs Branch of SPD for seven years. He has published extensively on aerospace issues, including Indian space militarisation aspirations and impact of space weaponisation on South Asian strategic stability. He is the recipient of Nuclear Non-Proliferation Fellowship from the Centre for Non-Proliferation Studies (CNS), California, US.

Event Chair

Air Marshal Asim Suleiman (Retd)

President CASS, Lahore

Event Coordinator

Air Commodore Khalid Iqbal (Retd)

Director National Security, CASS Lahore

Master of The Ceremony

Naba Fatima

Researcher, CASS Lahore

CASS LAhore

The Centre for Aerospace & Security Studies (CASS) was established in July 2021 to inform policymakers and the public about issues related to aerospace and security from an independent, non-partisan and future-centric analytical lens.

CASS Newsletter

Sign up to receive occasional research insights and event updates from CASS Lahore. We respect your privacy.

@2025 – All Right Reserved with CASS Lahore.